The Effects of Redistricting on Incumbents1
نویسندگان
چکیده
We analyze the effects of redistricting on the electoral fortunes of incumbent legislators, using voting data on U.S. congressional districts, state legislative districts, and statewide races. We find little evidence that redistricting helps incumbents in U.S. legislative elections. If anything, redrawing district lines reduces the average vote margin of those in districted offices compared with offices that are not districted, reduces electoral security, and increases turnover in the legislature.
منابع مشابه
The Effects of Redistricting on Distributive Outcomes
While the effects of redistricting on electoral outcomes have extensively been studied, little is known about its impact on policy outcomes. This paper argues that redistricting changes the incentives of legislators to serve their constituencies. This possibility arises because congressional redistricting in the United States typically involves violations of political boundaries. Examining the ...
متن کاملRepresentation through Legislative Redistricting : A Stochastic Model
This paper builds a stochastic model of the processes that give rise to observed patterns of representation and bias in congressional and state legislative elections. The analysis demonstrates that partisan swing and incumbency voting, concepts from the congressional elections literature, have determinate effects on representation and bias, concepts from the redistrictihg literature. The model ...
متن کامل17.267F13 Democracy In America: Final Paper Student 3 Example
Every ten years, after the census, every legislative district in the United States must be redrawn, and someone must do the drawing. This process is fraught with theoretical, practical, and political concerns, and there is no easy solution. However, while biased redistricting is impossible to eliminate, minimizing the partisan effects is still worthwhile. In particular, redistricting is hard be...
متن کاملBARD: Better Automated Redistricting
BARD is the first (and at time of writing, only) open source software package for general redistricting and redistricting analysis. BARD provides methods to create, display, compare, edit, automatically refine, evaluate, and profile political districting plans. BARD aims to provide a framework for scientific analysis of redistricting plans and to facilitate wider public participation in the cre...
متن کاملThe influence of the legislative redistricting of 2009: Methodological issues and first insights
In 2009, following a legislative redistricting lead by the right-wing, 18.1% of the French cities have moved from one constituency to another. The aim of this note is to provide some methodological issues about this redistricting and some insights about its influence on the electoral results. The main result goes in the sense of a partisan manipulation: due to the redistricting, the left-wing l...
متن کامل